Micah L. Sifry
January 16, 2007 - 8:12pm
I've been collecting string about Avaaz.org for a while now, but after I queried founders Ricken Patel and Tom Perriello (of ResPublica) and Paul Hilder, and they begged off on a pre-launch interview, I figured there was no hurry. But their site is now live (thanks Ruby for pinging me on that), so here's a first take.
Avaaz.org is using "The World in Action" as its tagline, and the first clue that this aims to be something different is the site, which comes in English, French, Korean, Chinese, Spanish and Portugese. The English version, however, is clearly NOT aimed at us Americans: it's got a photo of Tony Blair that reads "Even he is pulling out/Block the escalation in Iraq," and starts with this text: "George W Bush wants to pour more petrol on the fires burning in Iraq. But the new US Congress has the mandate to douse the flames. If they hear from all of us, they might find the guts to do it!" (Petrol is gasoline in British, by the way; and douse is to put out.)
At first glance this looks pretty cool and ambitious, a continuation of the "second superpower" movement that first reared its head in the global antiwar protests of early 2003. But I fear this well-intentioned effort could be just a horizontal move in online organizing, instead of a real step forward.
Though the name "MoveOn" appears nowhere on the Avaaz site, the giant online activist group's fingerprints are not hard to discern. For one, it's got the same model: build a big list, send them alerts to take action. Nothing net-centric, alas. No connecting members to each other or giving them a platform with tools for self-organizing. Here's how Avaaz's team describes their approach:
Using the latest technology, Avaaz.org empowers ordinary people from every corner of the globe to directly contact key global decision-makers, corporations and the media. By signing up to receive updates from Avaaz.org, members receive emails and text messages alerting them to new campaigns and opportunities to act online and offline, and to make a real difference on pressing global issues.
Does that really sound like the "latest technology"? (Actually, they are collecting cellphone/mobile numbers, which is an advance of sorts.) The site lists the Service Employees International Union as a founding partner along with GetUp.org.au, a MoveOn-style site that has had a big impact on Australian politics. Jeremy Heimans, founder of GetUp.org.au, is listed as a co-founder, along with Eli Pariser of MoveOn.
But what I'm hearing is that Avaaz is mainly a spawn of MoveOn. This makes some sense, when you consider that the American group has something like 600,000 email addresses of non-Americans in its list. This job description for the group's Chief Operating Officer makes clear the connection:
Global public opinion has been called the world’s “Second Superpower,” but a yawning gap persists between the views and values of the world’s peoples and the policies that govern them. Avaaz.org is a new activist community that will be launched in January 2007. As a joint venture with MoveOn.org, Avaaz.org will aim to fill this gap using the proven organizing techniques of online activism. The intention is to bring together millions of people around the world who favor a more progressive globalization -- building a well-organized public constituency around key global issues like poverty, climate change, human rights, global governance and major conflict. The organization is pursuing an ambitious growth path. It will ultimately be staffed with 20 full-time staff located in more than 8 countries, along with many volunteers. It is beginning with 700,000 members spread across 148 countries. It also has an Advisory Board that comprises politicians, diplomats, activists and celebrities from around the world. [Emphasis added.]
I also hear that in addition to getting support from MoveOn, Avaaz is also getting help from Aryeh Neier of the Open Society Institute and from Herb and Marion Sandler. However those are just unconfirmed rumors at this point. Cute-looking group, by the way. I'll add updates to this post as I get them.
UPDATE: I have learned that Open Society Institute indeed made a one-year grant of $150,000 to Res Publica last summer to help them get Avaaz off the ground.
UPDATE2: MoveOn's relationship to Avaaz.org is described this way by Eli Pariser: "We’re co-founders of Avaaz with Res Publica – nothing to hide there. We’ll be encouraging our international members to be a part, and raising some money for them. We think this model – which in the U.S. has brought 3 million folks into the political process, developed a new small-donor base for Democratic candidates, and helped win a number of key elections, can have an exciting impact worldwide."
UPDATE3: And Ricken Patel of Res Publica chimes in with this: "Each organization [MoveOn and ResPublica] has roughly equal international memberships that will be invited to join Avaaz (Res Publica has built a list of almost 400,000 at http://www.ceasefirecampaign.org/) and we also have had a campaign on Darfur since early 2004 at http://www.darfurgenocide.org/). I think it’s fair that we’re starting with a MoveOn model plus sms. (look for sms campaigns very soon). But we’re looking to innovate in all kinds of ways. We do want to try and get the right synergy between alerts and some kind of social networking model. We also want to try to get more creative about what online communities can support offline."
Source: http://personaldemocracy.com/node/1160
---87---
Avaaz
Paul Hilder is campaign director of Avaaz.org, the global web movement launched in 2007 which has since grown to 3.5 million members worldwide. Avaaz members take action together globally, regionally and nationally on issues including climate change, conflict in the Middle East, human rights and the economic crisis, and often campaign at the Europe-wide level. Previously, Paul co-founded the international affairs website openDemocracy.net and served on its board of directors. In the UK, he initiated and ran several campaigns and initiatives, including a consortium programme on citizen empowerment and local governance at the Young Foundation. He has worked on private diplomacy and conflict resolution in the Middle East, and in the European context. He is the author most recently of Contentious Citizens: civil society campaigning for progressive social change (Carnegie, 2007).**
CHARLOTTESVILLE, Va. -- The idea was pretty simple: Rep. Tom Perriello, a freshman Democrat who won an upset victory over his conservative predecessor last fall, would show up at the local high school auditorium on Tuesday night, take a few questions, and then meet one-on-one with some constituents. In and out in two hours, no problem.
...
Though Perriello has the kind of résumé that makes progressives swoon -- special advisor to the prosecution on war crimes trials in Sierra Leone, co-founder of DarfurGenocide.org and of Res Publica, a group that promotes social justice and civil society -- he represents a district that even the most optimistic Virginia Democrats had a hard time imagining turning blue before he won it. *
Paul Hilder is campaign director of Avaaz.org, the global web movement launched in 2007 which has since grown to 3.5 million members worldwide. Avaaz members take action together globally, regionally and nationally on issues including climate change, conflict in the Middle East, human rights and the economic crisis, and often campaign at the Europe-wide level. Previously, Paul co-founded the international affairs website openDemocracy.net and served on its board of directors. In the UK, he initiated and ran several campaigns and initiatives, including a consortium programme on citizen empowerment and local governance at the Young Foundation. He has worked on private diplomacy and conflict resolution in the Middle East, and in the European context. He is the author most recently of Contentious Citizens: civil society campaigning for progressive social change (Carnegie, 2007).**
CHARLOTTESVILLE, Va. -- The idea was pretty simple: Rep. Tom Perriello, a freshman Democrat who won an upset victory over his conservative predecessor last fall, would show up at the local high school auditorium on Tuesday night, take a few questions, and then meet one-on-one with some constituents. In and out in two hours, no problem.
...
Though Perriello has the kind of résumé that makes progressives swoon -- special advisor to the prosecution on war crimes trials in Sierra Leone, co-founder of DarfurGenocide.org and of Res Publica, a group that promotes social justice and civil society -- he represents a district that even the most optimistic Virginia Democrats had a hard time imagining turning blue before he won it. *
Ricken Patel is the co-founder of the web movement Avaaz.org, and he has a grand ambition: to make worldwide public opinion a decisive factor on key global issues from climate, to security, to human rights. ***
.