Westphalian Sovereignty

Westphalian Sovereignty

Westphalian sovereignty, sometimes known as state sovereignty, refers to the premise that each state possesses exclusive sovereignty over the territory that it controls.

TABLE OF CONTENT
Challenges to Westphalia
Defenders of Westphalia
The meaning of Westphalian


The principle is enshrined in the United Nations Charter, which states that it forms the basis of the modern international system of sovereign states and that it “shall not be infringed.”

“Nothing… shall give the United Nations the authority to intervene in matters that are fundamentally within the purview of the domestic jurisdiction of any particular state.

The concept maintains that every state, regardless of its size, possesses an equal claim to the freedom to exercise sovereignty. According to political scientists, the idea dates back to the Peace of Westphalia (1648), which put an end to both the Thirty Years’ War (1618–1648) and the Eighty Years’ War (1568–1648) The idea that one should stay out of other people’s business was refined during the 18th century.The Westphalian system reached its zenith in the 19th and 20th centuries, but in more recent times, it has come up against opposition from proponents of humanitarian intervention.

Challenges to Westphalia

Following the conclusion of the Cold War, there was a rise in international integration and, one could argue, a decrease in Westphalian sovereignty. A significant portion of the available literature was principally devoted to the criticism of realist models of international politics.

These are the types of models in which the concept of the state as a unitary agency is accepted as an axiomatic statement.In 1998, during a Symposium on the Continuing Political Relevance of the Peace of Westphalia,

NATO Secretary-General Javier Solana stated that “humanity and democracy [were] two principles that [were] essentially irrelevant to the original Westphalian order.” He also levelled the criticism that the original Westphalian order did not adequately account for human rights and democracy.

“The Westphalian system was not without its deficiencies.

To begin, the notion of sovereignty that it relied on likewise produced the framework for rivalry, rather than a community of states; moreover,

it produced the premise for exclusion, rather than integration.”

Tony Blair, then the Prime Minister of the United Kingdom, delivered a speech in Chicago in the year 1999 in which he “laid out a new, post-Westphalian,

‘Doctrine of the international community.'” Blair contended that globalisation had rendered the Westphalian method obsolete in this modern day.

After some time had passed,

The Daily Telegraph referred to Blair as “the man who brought in the post-Westphalian period.” Others have made the claim that the Westphalian system has been rendered obsolete as a result of globalisation.

Check out the complete UPSC Syllabus

Defenders of Westphalia

In spite of the fact that the Westphalian system was initially formed in early modern Europe, its most ardent supporters can currently be found in non-Western countries. In a declaration issued together in 2001, the leaders of China and Russia made a solemn commitment to “Concepts such as “humanitarian intervention” and “limited sovereignty”

Can be used to combat efforts that are being made to undermine the fundamental rules of international law.

Visit to know more about UPSC Preparation Books

The meaning of “Westphalian”

The European settlements of 1648 known as the Peace of Westphalia were responsible for bringing an end to both the German portion of the Thirty Years’ War and the Eighty Years’ War that had been raging between Spain and the Dutch. Beginning in the year 1644, the peace was negotiated in the cities of Münster and Osnabrück in the state of Westphalia.

The treaty between the Spanish and Dutch was signed on January 30th, 1648. The Holy Roman Emperor Ferdinand III, together with the other German princes, France, and Sweden, were all parties to the treaty that was signed on October 24, 1648.The only European powers that did not have a representative present at either of the two sessions were England, Poland, Russia, and the Ottoman Empire.

Read about UPSC Notes

The significance of the Treaty of Westphalia

Before one can begin to comprehend the importance of the Treaty of Westphalia, one needs to have a solid grounding in the background of the Protestant Reformation. A person who “protests” against the theology that is taught in Catholic churches is known as a Protestant. Martin Luther, a German theologian, was opposed to the doctrine as well as the practises of the Catholic Church.

As a result, he established his own denomination of Christianity, which is now known as Lutheranism. During the course of the following century, millions of Europeans abandoned the Catholic Church in favour of one of the numerous newly established Protestant faiths.

This movement resulted in a series of terrible conflicts across Europe between leaders of the Protestant and Catholic faiths.The most significant of these wars was the Thirty Years’ War, which took place between 1618 and 1648 and was fought mostly inside the boundaries of the Holy Roman Empire.

Conclusion

This is a term that is used in international affairs and is said to have originated from the Treaties of Westphalia in 1648, which put an end to the Thirty Years War. It is commonly understood to refer to a network of states or an international society that is made up of sovereign state entities that hold the monopoly on the use of force inside their own boundaries, which are acknowledged by each other.

The official diplomatic relationships that exist between the heads of state and governments are what are used to conduct international relations. International law is comprised of the treaties that are created (and broken) by the various sovereign entities that make up the world.


Source