Monday, November 16, 2026

Methodist Decline and Post-Denominational America

The faithful increasingly want their churches without the denominational baggage. 

by Mark Tooley 
November 7, 2026, 10:19 PM
 

Highland Park United Methodist Church Sanctuary in Texas (Adamtu hpumc/CC-BY-SA-4.0/Wikimedia Commons)


Once America’s biggest church and the biggest Protestant denomination for most of the 20th century, the United Methodist Church has plunged from 11 million members in 1968 to 3.8 million in 2025, with over 174,000 members lost in one year.

As recently as 2019, the Mainline Protestant denomination had 6 million members. After a 50-year debate over sexuality, specifically same sex unions, it finally decided to split. Between 2019 and 2023, the denomination offered a four-year window for congregations to leave with their property. Nearly 8,000 churches, almost all of them conservative, left, leaving the denomination with a remaining 20,000 churches and a 1.2 million membership loss in 2024.

American non-Catholic Christianity is now post-denominational.

The 2025 loss of 174,000 perhaps represents the new post-schism annual loss number going forward. If so, United Methodism would have 22 years before the last member turns out the lights. But the denomination almost certainly will not last that long. Denominational loyalties in America are collapsing, and very few non-elderly are very committed to United Methodism, or any other specific denomination. American non-Catholic Christianity is now post-denominational. (RELATED: Major Left-Leaning Lutheran Seminary Announces Sale of Historic Campus)

Perhaps more significant than the latest membership loss statistic is the recent departure of United Methodism’s second largest congregation, Highland Park Church in Dallas, Texas. With 15,000 members and an annual income of over $48 million, Highland Park has long operated according to its own sights, while still financially supporting the denomination, paying $12 million since 2022.

Highland Park United Methodist Church has changed its name to Highland Park Methodist Church, declaring its independence by an over 90 percent vote by the congregation. Among those 90 percent were George W. and Laura Bush, who issued a public statement affirming their support for the move.

The church had not left during the official 2019-2023 schism and did not take an official position on the sexuality debate. It does not host same sex unions. Traditionally, its congregation has included conservative businesspeople and progressive academics who work across the street at Southern Methodist Seminary and its United Methodist Seminary, which is called Perkins School of Theology. But its main motivation seems to be that it no longer sees the utility of the denomination. (RELATED: Paganism Casts Its Spell Over Methodist Seminary)


The local United Methodist bishop is dissolving Highland Park Methodist Church and has set up a new continuing Highland Park United Methodist Church at a site several miles away. On its first Sunday, only about one hundred attended, fewer than one-quarter who had voted against the split. Meanwhile, nearly 8,000 people attended Highland Park Methodist that same Sunday.

Across the nation, courts typically rule in favor of denominations claiming control of local church properties. But Texas courts have generally ruled against denominations. Expect that Highland Park Methodist will prevail against the local United Methodist bishop, who, rather than negotiating, seems to operate as if it’s 1960 instead of 2026.

Denominational authorities, especially Mainline Protestants, long commanded deference and respect. But in the new post-denominational age, many, if not most, local church members wonder why they should care about a distant prelate instead of their congregation making its own decisions.

Interestingly, the newly elected U.S. Senator from Kansas pastors United Methodism’s largest congregation, Church of the Resurrection in Kansas City. Adam Hamilton, originally from the conservative and Pentecostal Assemblies of God denomination, founded his church in 1990. It now has 25,000 members. He shifted to a more liberal stance on sexuality 20 years ago and led the effort to overturn United Methodism’s traditional stance on sexuality, which finally prevailed in 2024 after the schism. (RELATED: What’s the Matter With Kansas (the Senate Race, That Is)?)

Hamilton says he will, as U.S. Senator, remain as pastor at Church of the Resurrection. His example recalls Congressman Emmanuel Cleaver, also of Kansas City, who for years served in both the U.S. House of Representatives and as a United Methodist pastor, until succeeded in the pulpit by his son.

Why does a megachurch need a denomination?

It will be interesting to watch if Church of the Resurrection, after Hamilton leaves the pulpit at some point, long survives without his unique talents. And if it does, will it not be tempted to follow the example of Highland Park Methodist Church and exit the denomination? Why does a megachurch need a denomination?

Small churches, with congregations of a few dozen mostly elderly people, typically do not have the wherewithal to exit their denominations. But larger and more vital congregations in denominations will be increasingly impatient with denominational commitments, whether to liberal Mainline or to more conservative evangelical denominations.

It’s often noted that nondenominational churches, if collectively a denomination, would be America’s largest. And growing Christianity in America is almost entirely nondenominational. Small niche denominations like the Presbyterian Church in America and the Anglican Church in North America are growing slightly. The 3-million-member Assemblies of God enjoyed steady growth for years until the pandemic, after which it lost several hundred thousand members. It is now growing again but has not yet returned to the pre-pandemic membership. The 12-million-member Southern Baptist Convention has lost nearly 4 million members over two decades and almost certainly will continue to shrink.

Progressive-led Mainline Protestant denominations began declining in membership in the mid-1960s and their remaining shelf life is limited. But their decline foreshadowed a larger shift against established institutions. Today’s American Christianity is not only increasingly post-denominational; it is also online and self-curated. American Protestants and Evangelicals are no longer definitively instructed by their local churches, much less denominations.

Perhaps this is neither good nor bad, just different. But the further individualization of American Christianity is having and will have further wide social implications that cannot yet be fully appreciated.



No comments: